The stage of Kiyomizu-dera, Kyoto
TSUREZURE
A Cultural Economic Sphere
On earning through culture
Whenever I am invited to give a talk or a seminar, I have long said the same thing. Japan should earn far more from its rich culture. No, it must.
Raise the subject of money where culture is being discussed, and some people frown. But a culture that cannot earn its keep will not last. If artisans cannot make a living, their skills die out. The same goes for those who make the materials and those who make the tools (see Withering Roots).
Look at Europe’s luxury maisons and this becomes very clear. What they deal in is leather goods, fashion, jewelry, wine and spirits, furniture. Trace any of it back, and you find handwork and products rooted in the culture of a place. In essence, it is not so different from Japanese craft. The difference lies in whether there is a system that prices such things together with their culture and delivers them to the world.
On this path, France and Italy are far ahead. What is more, they are keenly aware of their own advantage. They know full well that the names of their places, their history, the lineages of their artisans are assets no other country can imitate, and they set their prices accordingly. That is why their margins are, on the whole, so rich. They have no reason to sell cheaply.
In nominal GDP, France ranks seventh in the world and Italy ninth. Both sit below Japan. In Japan, one often hears calls to win back our ranking, to return to where we once stood. That is fine, but which of us is actually getting the substance? They take their holidays at leisure, they are proud of their tables and their townscapes, and they earn from the world through their own culture. To my eyes, they look far happier.
Earning through culture has many virtues.
First, it is hard to copy. Copy and paste a culture, and the backlash obligingly follows. Borrow someone else’s culture carelessly, and the world will not keep quiet. Without relying on patents or trademarks, culture protects itself.
Second, the makers can take pride in their work. Rather than churning out volume in a race to cut prices, they can work with their own culture on their shoulders. And when the work is something to be proud of, young people appear who want to carry it on.
Third, the clientele is good. People who understand a culture and are willing to pay for it do not choose things on price alone. They stay with you for a long time, and they take good care of what they buy.
The earning power of culture does not stop at a single product or a single company. Think of Kiyomizu-dera or Nikko Toshogu. For centuries they have kept drawing people. The teahouses before their gates, the souvenir shops, the inns, the artisans who maintain the buildings have all shared in the benefit. Over long stretches of time, culture feeds a great many people around it.
I use the phrase “cultural economic sphere.” This is not about selling off culture piece by piece for the sake of the economy. The order is the reverse. First comes culture, and society. The economy should sit beneath them, as the foundation that supports them. In today’s world, the economy has taken the seat of honor for far too long.
The difference shows in the stance of the state as well. The budget of Japan’s Agency for Cultural Affairs is around 100 billion yen a year, a mere quarter to a fifth of France’s cultural budget. Whether one sees culture as something that costs money or as something that enriches a nation: that difference shows up plainly in the numbers.
Even so, I sense the tide is turning. Everyone is beginning, dimly, to feel how much culture matters. In recent years, young people who build businesses starting from culture, so-called culturepreneurs, have been appearing one after another, and that is heartening. They are trying to make craft, food, inns and festivals stand on their own as businesses, rather than as things to be protected. Mind you, I have thought of myself as a culturepreneur for a quarter of a century. I have made my living from culture since before the word existed. My honest feeling is that, at last, my companions are growing in number.
Beneath Japan’s feet lies a deep context, layered over more than a thousand years: the tea ceremony, Noh, gardens, vessels, architecture, the words of the seasons. None of these exists anywhere but here. In the race to make things cheaply and in quantity, we may no longer be able to win. But if we compete with what cannot be imitated, Japan is one of the world’s great resource-rich nations. Craft, I believe, is a growth industry with nothing but room to grow.
Culture draws people, and people pay for it. That payment reaches the artisans, reaches those who make the materials and the tools, and in turn nurtures the culture again. I want to build that cycle, in which the economy supports culture.
AMUAMI is meant as a small entrance to that cycle. Earning is not the goal. It is a means of handing culture on to the next generation. And that is exactly why I want to earn properly.
Yudai Tachikawa, Founder of AMUAMI and ubushina